Skip to main content

The Statistic

There are times when nothing makes sense. The universe, despite its patterns, seems random, chaotic, and even cruel. Yet, reality simply is. We can study statistics, predict possible outcomes, develop complex models for nearly every contained system… yet on the personal level those models are useless.

We can predict that one person of every thousand contracts a given disease, a numeric formula safely separating the person from the calculation. Risk management, economics, and various sciences step in for the analysis. Everyone involved digests the numbers and accepts them as theoretical models.

Yet the model is meaningless to the statistic… that one person.

Parents hear statistics and worry. Contexts are often missing, especially comparison to other statistics. How dangerous is something, really, when compared to other risks?

We know travel by car is very dangerous, but it is familiar. We worry about the unusual, the strange.

In 2004, 27 children died in cribs according to the U.S. National Center for Health Statistics. That's it... 27. By comparison, 6047 people died that year trying to cross the street. Yet, we worry a lot more about cribs than street crossings.

Two years ago, six children were harmed by swimming pool filtration systems. One was fatal, sadly, at a Minnesota country club. Now, we have state and federal regulations covering filtration system inspections.

What does this have to do with autism?

Statistics and anecdotes compete for the attention of parents. Statistics and risk analysis might indicate one thing, as measured and tested by scientists and researchers, but parents hear and read personal stories. These stories matter more.

In fact, I've read numerous studies that show people who read a personal story simply cannot relate to the statistics afterwards. You read about a child's negative reaction to a treatment, a vaccine, an over-the-counter medication, an educational strategy, and you remember that negative story. Negatives are far, far more memorable. Recalling negatives helps a species survive -- we evolved to be cautious.

Personal stories affect us. Statistics don't. That's why horror stories about dangerous cribs, swimming pool filters, and even exploding cell phones scare us. We remember those stories, especially if we lack enough positive offsets. Because we don't have an accident every time we ride in the car, we rationalize the risks. We understand driving does not always equal death. But, how familiar are we with vaccines? We don't get them every day. How familiar are we with special diets? Hyperbolic chambers?

The unfamiliar is hard to understand -- even with statistical analysis.

No matter how many numbers I cite, no matter how scientifically and statistically valid the results, what matters to a parent is what he or she has read, seen, or heard anecdotally. The people they meet, the other parents they talk to, the conference gatherings, all matter more
than any statistics. It's human -- lot logical, but human.

And, even with statistics, that one person who does react to a "statistically safe" treatment, medication, etc., won't care about the statistics. We want "safe" to mean "0.0% risk" and that's simply not possible. So the one injury, the one horror story, matters.

I worry about tornadoes. I know that statistically, the last deadly and destructive tornado where I live was nearly 20 years ago. I still worry. It's not logical, as least not statistically, but tell that to the families affected by a storm. They aren't mere statistics.

We try to avoid risks. Curiously, we don't always avoid the statistically significant risks. We avoid those risks that scare us the most.


  1. Your thesis probably explains the differential fear of animals: a mountain lion kills one person every second year, and it ignites a panic with people demanding that someone "do something" and wondering if they should take a gun with them when they hike in the woods, while being unmoved by the fact that deer kill a hundred times as many people every year as every other sort of wildlife (except microbes) put together.


Post a Comment

Comments violating the policies of this blog will not be approved for posting. Language and content should be appropriate for all readers and maintain a polite tone. Thank you.

Popular posts from this blog

Autistic Burnout

Summer demands a lot of social energy, especially for parents. For autistics, the never-ending social calendar of summer can cause serious autistic burnout. Host C. S. Wyatt discusses his need to find a balance between social demands and self-care. Check out this episode!

Autism, Asperger's, and IQ

"Aren't people with Asperger's more likely to be geniuses? Isn't genius related to autism?" A university student asked this in a course I am teaching. The class discussion was covering neurological differences, free will, and the nature versus nurture debate. The textbook for the course includes sidebars on the brain and behavior throughout chapters on ethics and morality. This student was asking a question reflecting media portrayals of autism spectrum disorders, social skills difficulties, and genius. I did not address this question from a personal perspective in class, but I have when speaking to groups of parents, educators, and caregivers. Some of the reasons these questions arise, as mentioned above, are media portrayals and news coverage of autism. Examples include: Television shows with gifted characters either identified with or assumed to have autistic traits: Alphas, Big Bang Theory, Bones, Rizzoli and Isles, Touch, and others. Some would include

Free eBook on Autism and Relationships

This blog post is a bit unusual. I am testing to see if visitors can download a free eBook from this blog. I have linked to the file, which sits on our Web server. We have successfully tested the ePub edition of A Spectrum of Relationships . Only the abridged ePub edition is available for free at this time, not an Amazon Kindle edition, due to Amazon's policy requesting only full, commercial editions from small publishers. Until the text is revised and edited, I'm not comfortable publishing it formally. The commercial version will be released for the Amazon Kindle as well as other devices. In fact, it might be released first for the Kindle, if things go as planned. Downloading an ePub can be a challenge: some browsers try to open the file directly. To download the ePub, you might have to "right-click" and download the linked file. If you have the ePub extension installed, the FireFox browser will open the ePub correctly. A Spectrum of Relationships (ePub file) [